Skip to content
  • HOME
  • SHOP
    • GIFT CARD
  • BLOG
  • TIMELINE
  • CONTACT
  • WHOLESALE
  • WooCommerce Cart1
    • Three Flavor Fudge Box
      Three Flavor Fudge Box - 24 oz.1 x $36.98
    • View Cart
      Checkout

Shop

  • Amish Made Candy

    Amish Made Candy (1)

  • Amish Pie Fillings, Salsa and Syrups,

    Amish Pie Fillings, Salsa and Syrups, (6)

  • BBQ Sauces & Quail Eggs

    BBQ Sauces & Quail Eggs (2)

  • Bulk Candy and Fudge

    Bulk Candy and Fudge (2)

  • Corporate Gift Giving

    Corporate Gift Giving (3)

  • Fresh Nuts

    Fresh Nuts (1)

  • Fruits & Vegetables

    Fruits & Vegetables (5)

  • Fudge

    Fudge (8)

  • Fundraising

    Fundraising (1)

  • Gift Giving

    Gift Giving (16)

  • Jams-Jellies-Butters-Mustards

    Jams-Jellies-Butters-Mustards (8)

  • No Sugar Added Products

    No Sugar Added Products (4)

  • Premium Candy

    Premium Candy (13)

  • Sort by Popularity
    • Sort by Default Order
    • Sort by Name
    • Sort by Price
    • Sort by Date
    • Sort by Popularity
    • Sort by Rating
  • Show 12 Products
    • Show 12 Products
    • Show 24 Products
    • Show 36 Products
  • Amish Pie Filling

    Amish Pie Filling – 32 Oz Jar

    $20.99

    32 Oz of delicious ready to use Amish pie filling and No Sugar Added Pie Filling

    Mix or match 2 jars and add to cart.

  • Amish Fresh Made Salsa

    Amish Fresh Made Salsa 16 oz. Jar

    $14.99

    Fresh 16 oz. Salsa available in over 40 flavors. All of our salsas are made with only the finest ingredients.  You won’t find any preservatives or artificial flavors or colorings, or unnatural sugars.

    Mix or Match 2 Flavors. Add 2 jars to cart of each flavor desired.

     

  • Amish Jams

    Amish Jams 16 oz. Jar

    $14.99

    Jams using all natural ingredients and no preservatives.

  • Fudge – 1 Lb (Buy Two Pounds and Get 1/2 Pound Chocolate Free)

    $26.98

    Buy Two Pounds of any flavor and Get 1/2 Pound Chocolate Free

  • Licorice Twists

    Licorice Twists – 16 Oz Pkg

    $8.33

    Licorice Twists - 16 Oz Pkg. 9 delicious flavors to choose from.

  • No Sugar Added Jam

    No Sugar Added Jam 16 oz.

    $14.99

    Mix or Match 2 Jars. Add 2 jars to cart

  • Ready to use No Sugar Added Pie Filling and Topping

    Ready to use No Sugar Added Pie Filling and Topping

    $20.99

    32 oz. Jar. All-Natural Pie Filling and Topping sweetened with fruit juices. Simply pour into ready to use pie crust then bake or pour over cheesecake, ice cream, and tarts.

    Mix or Match Flavors and add 2 jars to cart

  • Amish Fruit & Vegetable

    Amish Fruit & Vegetable 32 oz.

    $20.36

    Mix or Match 2 flavors. Add 2 jars to cart.

  • Fudge – 7 Oz Tub

    $9.25

    Mix or match 2 flavors of freshly made to order fudge flavors.

    Add 2 tubs to cart.

  • Pickled Quail Eggs

    Pickled Quail Eggs 16 oz. Jar

    $14.99

    16 oz. Quail Eggs

    Mix or Match 2 Jars. Add 2 jars to cart

  • Pickled Baby Beets

    Pickled Baby Beets (2 Jars)

    $28.98

    Amish made pickled baby beets - 16 oz. jar. Sooooo good!

  • Jam and Jellies

    Jam and Jellies – 8 oz. Jars

    $9.99

    Mix or Match 3 Jars. Add 3 jars to cart

  • Candy – Triple Dipped Malted Milk Balls

    $42.50

    Crunchy Malt Balls surrounded in three layers of milk chocolate 

    Savor the delectable delight of malted milk balls, each meticulously triple-dipped in luxuriously creamy milk chocolate, crafted to perfection for the ultimate indulgence. These exquisite treats start with a crunchy, airy heart of malted milk that delivers a harmonious blend of sweetness and malt flavor, creating a foundation that’s both nostalgic and satisfying. The magic unfolds as these malted milk balls undergo a triple dipping process in the finest milk chocolate, ensuring each piece is sumptuously coated for a rich, velvety texture that melts seamlessly in your mouth.

    The repeated layers of chocolate not only enhance the depth of flavor but also contribute to a wonderfully indulgent, creamy finish that makes each malted milk ball a tiny piece of heaven. This meticulous attention to detail results in a gourmet chocolate experience that celebrates the classic taste of malted milk balls while elevating them to a new level of luxury.

    Perfect for gifting or treating yourself, these triple-dipped malted milk balls are a testament to the art of chocolate making. They promise to satisfy your sweet cravings with their perfect balance of crunchy malt and smooth, rich chocolate. Dive into the exquisite pleasure of these malted milk balls and let each bite take you on a sumptuous journey from farm to table.

  • Amish No Sugar Added Butters

    Amish No Sugar Added Butters

    $29.98

    Butters sweetened with fruit juices

  • Bagged Candy

    Bagged Candy 13 oz. (2 Bags)

    $25.99

    Arndts famous fresh candy ready to eat or for gift giving.

  • Amish Made All Natural Fruit Butters

    Amish Made All Natural Fruit Butters

    $29.98

    Amish made butters made in small batches using only wholesome ingredients.

  • Amish Made Canned Vegetables (Mix or Match 2 Flavors)

    $14.99

    Mix or match flavors of 2 Jars

    Add 2 Jars of desired flavors to cart.

  • Planks Amish Made

    Syrup – Planks Amish Made 16 oz. Jar

    $9.58

    Mix or Match 3 Jars. Add 3 Jars to cart.

  • No Sugar Added Jam

    No Sugar Added Jam 8 oz.

    $9.99

    8 oz. No Sugar Added Jam

    Mix or Match 3 Jars. Add 3 Jars to Cart

  • Amish Mustards

    Amish Mustards

    $22.99

    Amish Made Mustards in 8 Flavors

  • BBQ sauce

    BBQ Sauce

    $14.99

    BBQ Sauces great for grilling or just dipping

  • Specialty Nuts

    Specialty Nuts (2 bags)

    $24.99

    Fresh Nuts

  • Assorted flavors Taffy – 8 Oz

    $7.66

    Taffy - 8 Oz Pkg. All the fun flavors you remember - as fresh as if you just made it yourself.

  • Fruit

    Fruit & Creamy Dressings 12 oz. (Mix or Match 3 Jars)

    $11.25

    Our unique dressing is Amish made and produced in small batches using the highest quality ingredients. Try this refreshing dressing on your favorite salad or as a dip for vegetables.

    Mix or Match 3 Flavors. Add 3 jars to cart

  • Three Flavor Fudge Box

    Three Flavor Fudge Box – 24 oz.

    $36.98

    Three Flavor Fudge Sampler box including Chocolate, Peanut Butter, and Vanilla Praline. Nestled in a gift box great for gift giving or a special treat for yourself.

    Each cut fudge is sealed in protective wrapping for a fresh product.

  • Amish Made Candy

    Amish Made Candy 8 oz. Bags (Mix or Match 3 Flavors)

    $11.25

    Mix or match flavors of 3 Flavors

    Add 3 Choices of desired flavors to cart.

  • Stuffed Olives

    Stuffed Olives 16 oz. Jar (Mix or Match 2 Flavors)

    $14.99

    These mild flavorful olives are the classic martini & Bloody Mary garnish. Hand stuffed for a fresh savory flavor.

    Mix or Match 2 flavors.

    Please add 2 jars to cart

  • Milk Chocolate

    Candy – Milk Chocolate Toasted Coconut Haystacks 14 oz. Gift Box

    $35.98

    What a wonderful way to treat a loved one or yourself. This candy is shredded, toasted coconut and then rolled in milk chocolate.

     

  • Pecan Turtles Gift Box

    Candy – Pecan Caramel Patties Gift Box – 13 oz.

    $35.98

    Treat yourself to fresh Pecans smothered in gooey Caramel and coated with Milk Chocolate.

  • Gift Box

    Gift Box – 12 Oz Fudge

    $26.98

    Gift Box – 12 oz. of delicious fudge – please [...]

  • Salt Water Taffy Bulk

    Taffy Bulk

    $23.98

    2.82 Pound Bulk Saltwater Taffy great for candy bars or treat bags.

  • Premium Candy Tubs

    Premium Candy Tubs (2 Tubs)

    $19.98

    Safety Sealed Tub of Candy

  • Handcrafted Brittle

    Handcrafted Brittle 6 oz. Bag (4 bags)

    $32.98

    Handmade to order fresh brittle

  • Sorghum Molasses

    Sorghum Molasses

    $24.98

    Amish made sorghum molasses

  • Amish Honey

    $23.98

    Amish honey, fresh packaged from locally gathered honey.

  • Milk Chocolate

    Candy – Milk Chocolate Maple Creams Gift Box – 15 Pieces

    $25.98

    Milk chocolate with a creamy maple flavored center

12Next
  • 106 W. Washington Street Newton, IL 62448

  • 1-(800) 753-8343

  • 1-(618) 783-2183

  • orders@fudgery.com

USEFUL LINKS

  • About
  • Delivery Information
  • Fudge Ingredients
  • Fudge Ingredients Reduced Sugar
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions

PRODUCTS

  • Fudge Flavors
  • Amish made
  • Other Products
  • Price List

CONNECT WITH US

© 1913 - 2025 • Arndt's Fudgery, LLC • All Rights Reserved • Developed by 123ehost

Page load link
Go to Top