Amish Made Gift Packs 3 oz. assortment of jams, jellies, [...]

Fresh made to order brittles using butter for that melt in your mouth candy.

Mix or match flavors of 3 Flavors

Add 3 Choices of desired flavors to cart.

Mix or match flavors of 2 Jars

Add 2 Jars of desired flavors to cart.

These mild flavorful olives are the classic martini & Bloody Mary garnish. Hand stuffed for a fresh savory flavor.

Mix or Match 2 flavors.

Please add 2 jars to cart

Our unique dressing is Amish made and produced in small batches using the highest quality ingredients. Try this refreshing dressing on your favorite salad or as a dip for vegetables.

Mix or Match 3 Flavors. Add 3 jars to cart

32 oz. Jar. All-Natural Pie Filling and Topping sweetened with fruit juices. Simply pour into ready to use pie crust then bake or pour over cheesecake, ice cream, and tarts.

Mix or Match Flavors and add 2 jars to cart

High profit fundraising.

Email Charlotte@fudgery.com for more information

For that hard to buy for person on your gift [...]

Mix or Match 2 flavors. Add 2 jars to cart.

Fresh 16 oz. Salsa available in over 40 flavors. All of our salsas are made with only the finest ingredients.  You won’t find any preservatives or artificial flavors or colorings, or unnatural sugars.

Mix or Match 2 Flavors. Add 2 jars to cart of each flavor desired.

5 Pound Loaf

16 oz. Quail Eggs

Mix or Match 2 Jars. Add 2 jars to cart

Arndts famous fresh candy ready to eat or for gift giving.

Rock Crystal Suckers. USA Made

2.82 Pound Bulk Saltwater Taffy great for candy bars or treat bags.

Amish made sorghum molasses

8 oz. No Sugar Added Jam

Mix or Match 3 Jars. Add 3 Jars to Cart

Mix or Match 2 Jars. Add 2 jars to cart

Safety Sealed Tub of Candy

Fresh Nuts

Mix or Match 3 Jars. Add 3 jars to cart

Amish honey, fresh packaged from locally gathered honey.

Butters sweetened with fruit juices

Amish Made Mustards in 8 Flavors

Mix or Match 3 Jars. Add 3 Jars to cart.

Jams using all natural ingredients and no preservatives.

BBQ Sauces great for grilling or just dipping

Amish made butters made in small batches using only wholesome ingredients.

Sugar free Taffy - 7 oz pkg. Assorted flavors - as fresh as if you just made it yourself.

Taffy - 8 Oz Pkg. All the fun flavors you remember - as fresh as if you just made it yourself.

Licorice Twists - 16 Oz Pkg. 9 delicious flavors to choose from.

Crunchy Malt Balls surrounded in three layers of milk chocolate 

Savor the delectable delight of malted milk balls, each meticulously triple-dipped in luxuriously creamy milk chocolate, crafted to perfection for the ultimate indulgence. These exquisite treats start with a crunchy, airy heart of malted milk that delivers a harmonious blend of sweetness and malt flavor, creating a foundation that’s both nostalgic and satisfying. The magic unfolds as these malted milk balls undergo a triple dipping process in the finest milk chocolate, ensuring each piece is sumptuously coated for a rich, velvety texture that melts seamlessly in your mouth.

The repeated layers of chocolate not only enhance the depth of flavor but also contribute to a wonderfully indulgent, creamy finish that makes each malted milk ball a tiny piece of heaven. This meticulous attention to detail results in a gourmet chocolate experience that celebrates the classic taste of malted milk balls while elevating them to a new level of luxury.

Perfect for gifting or treating yourself, these triple-dipped malted milk balls are a testament to the art of chocolate making. They promise to satisfy your sweet cravings with their perfect balance of crunchy malt and smooth, rich chocolate. Dive into the exquisite pleasure of these malted milk balls and let each bite take you on a sumptuous journey from farm to table.

Handmade to order fresh brittle

32 Oz of delicious ready to use Amish pie filling and No Sugar Added Pie Filling

Mix or match 2 jars and add to cart.

Amish made pickled baby beets - 16 oz. jar. Sooooo good!