Arndt’s Fudgery handcrafts every fudge-filled heart fresh to order, making them the perfect sweet gift for any occasion.

Mix or Match 2 flavors. Add 2 jars to cart.

Gift Basket - delicious assortment of Amish products. Gifts for any occasion.

Basket includes the following (products may vary slightly):

7oz. Chocolate Fudge, 8 oz. Flavored Maple Syrup, 8 oz. Strawberry Rhubarb Jam , 7 oz. Honey Mustard, 8 oz. Apple Butter. 6 oz. bag Peanut Brittle, 16 oz. bag licorice.

Amish honey, fresh packaged from locally gathered honey.

Jams using all natural ingredients and no preservatives.

Amish made butters made in small batches using only wholesome ingredients.

Mix or match flavors of 3 Flavors

Add 3 Choices of desired flavors to cart.

Mix or match flavors of 2 Jars

Add 2 Jars of desired flavors to cart.

Amish Made Gift Packs 3 oz. assortment of jams, jellies, [...]

Fresh 16 oz. Salsa available in over 40 flavors. All of our salsas are made with only the finest ingredients.  You won’t find any preservatives or artificial flavors or colorings, or unnatural sugars.

Mix or Match 2 Flavors. Add 2 jars to cart of each flavor desired.

Amish Made Mustards in 8 Flavors

Butters sweetened with fruit juices