Shop

Candy – Milk Chocolate Toasted Coconut Haystacks 14 oz. Gift Box
$35.98
What a wonderful way to treat a loved one or yourself. This candy is shredded, toasted coconut and then rolled in milk chocolate.
Rock Crystal Candy Suckers
$34.98
Rock Crystal Suckers. USA Made
Gift Box – 24 Oz Fudge
$34.98
Gift Box – 24 oz. of delicious fudge – please [...]
Gift Tin of Fudge – 16 Oz
$34.95
Tin of Fudge Beautiful tin gift box with 16 oz. [...]
Handcrafted Brittle 6 oz. Bag (4 bags)
$32.98
Handmade to order fresh brittle
12 oz. Fudge Filled Heart Shaped Container
$32.25
Arndt’s Fudgery handcrafts every fudge-filled heart fresh to order, making them the perfect sweet gift for any occasion.
Amish No Sugar Added Butters
$29.98
Butters sweetened with fruit juices
Amish Mustards
$22.99
Amish Made Mustards in 8 Flavors
Amish Made All Natural Fruit Butters
$29.98
Amish made butters made in small batches using only wholesome ingredients.
Amish Made Gift Packs
$28.90
Amish Made Gift Packs 3 oz. assortment of jams, jellies, [...]
Amish Honey
$23.98
Amish honey, fresh packaged from locally gathered honey.
Hand Made Brittle Gift Box in Assorted Flavors
$26.98
Fresh made to order brittles using butter for that melt in your mouth candy.