Skip to content
  • HOME
  • SHOP
    • GIFT CARD
  • BLOG
  • TIMELINE
  • CONTACT
  • WHOLESALE
  • WooCommerce Cart1
    • Three Flavor Fudge Box
      Three Flavor Fudge Box - 24 oz.1 x $36.98
    • View Cart
      Checkout

Shop

  • Amish Made Candy

    Amish Made Candy (1)

  • Amish Pie Fillings, Salsa and Syrups,

    Amish Pie Fillings, Salsa and Syrups, (6)

  • BBQ Sauces & Quail Eggs

    BBQ Sauces & Quail Eggs (2)

  • Bulk Candy and Fudge

    Bulk Candy and Fudge (2)

  • Corporate Gift Giving

    Corporate Gift Giving (3)

  • Fresh Nuts

    Fresh Nuts (1)

  • Fruits & Vegetables

    Fruits & Vegetables (5)

  • Fudge

    Fudge (8)

  • Fundraising

    Fundraising (1)

  • Gift Giving

    Gift Giving (16)

  • Jams-Jellies-Butters-Mustards

    Jams-Jellies-Butters-Mustards (8)

  • No Sugar Added Products

    No Sugar Added Products (4)

  • Premium Candy

    Premium Candy (13)

  • Sort by Name
    • Sort by Default Order
    • Sort by Name
    • Sort by Price
    • Sort by Date
    • Sort by Popularity
    • Sort by Rating
  • Show 12 Products
    • Show 12 Products
    • Show 24 Products
    • Show 36 Products
  • Tin of Fudge

    Gift Tin of Fudge – 16 Oz

    $34.95

    Tin of Fudge Beautiful tin gift box with 16 oz. [...]

  • Tin of Fudge

    Gift Tin of Fudge – 32 Oz

    $47.75

    Tin of Fudge Beautiful tin gift box with 32 oz. [...]

  • Three Flavor Fudge Box

    Three Flavor Fudge Box – 24 oz.

    $36.98

    Three Flavor Fudge Sampler box including Chocolate, Peanut Butter, and Vanilla Praline. Nestled in a gift box great for gift giving or a special treat for yourself.

    Each cut fudge is sealed in protective wrapping for a fresh product.

  • Salt Water Taffy Bulk

    Taffy Bulk

    $23.98

    2.82 Pound Bulk Saltwater Taffy great for candy bars or treat bags.

  • Sugar Free Salt Water

    Sugar Free – Taffy – 7 Oz (3 Bags)

    $22.98

    Sugar free Taffy - 7 oz pkg. Assorted flavors - as fresh as if you just made it yourself.

  • Stuffed Olives

    Stuffed Olives 16 oz. Jar (Mix or Match 2 Flavors)

    $14.99

    These mild flavorful olives are the classic martini & Bloody Mary garnish. Hand stuffed for a fresh savory flavor.

    Mix or Match 2 flavors.

    Please add 2 jars to cart

  • Specialty Nuts

    Specialty Nuts (2 bags)

    $24.99

    Fresh Nuts

  • Sorghum Molasses

    Sorghum Molasses

    $24.98

    Amish made sorghum molasses

  • Assorted flavors Taffy – 8 Oz

    $7.66

    Taffy - 8 Oz Pkg. All the fun flavors you remember - as fresh as if you just made it yourself.

  • Rock Crystal Candy Suckers

    Rock Crystal Candy Suckers

    $34.98

    Rock Crystal Suckers. USA Made

  • Ready to use No Sugar Added Pie Filling and Topping

    Ready to use No Sugar Added Pie Filling and Topping

    $20.99

    32 oz. Jar. All-Natural Pie Filling and Topping sweetened with fruit juices. Simply pour into ready to use pie crust then bake or pour over cheesecake, ice cream, and tarts.

    Mix or Match Flavors and add 2 jars to cart

  • Premium Candy Tubs

    Premium Candy Tubs (2 Tubs)

    $19.98

    Safety Sealed Tub of Candy

12Next
  • 106 W. Washington Street Newton, IL 62448

  • 1-(800) 753-8343

  • 1-(618) 783-2183

  • orders@fudgery.com

USEFUL LINKS

  • About
  • Delivery Information
  • Fudge Ingredients
  • Fudge Ingredients Reduced Sugar
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions

PRODUCTS

  • Fudge Flavors
  • Amish made
  • Other Products
  • Price List

CONNECT WITH US

© 1913 - 2025 • Arndt's Fudgery, LLC • All Rights Reserved • Developed by 123ehost

Page load link
Go to Top